Talk:Battle Formations/@comment-173.65.114.44-20131229091944/@comment-24477712-20140129110446

That is due to the fact, that barbarian breaks even with soldier at 57.14% of your combined blank attack stat

that means that out of all your cards stats, not including any boosts from guild classes (or even captain card boost on no class) if 57.15% or more of your attack is sourced from cards of your captain cards realm, then barbarian will provide a higher attack than soldier.

due to you having relatively balanced attack values on your cards and 6 of them being chaos, barb is superior for you. if you were to replace one of your chaos cards like arimas with a justice or genesis card, then soldier would bring you a higher boost