Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-24392826-20140107141146/@comment-7743566-20140108002719

if you think being double or triple their level or attack is bad you don't know what uber low levels have to deal with, granted at level 2 there aren't that many other low levels that are in guilds that have high level players except people with alts, but it's kinda pathetic when a lvl 180 player can beat and steal treasure from a level2 player simply because they are responding to an aid request, i don't care how uber the lvl2 player is, even a crappy player at level 180 should be able to easily double, triple or quadruple the highest def of the lvl2 player (even without formations/skill bonuses)

but back to your question, this type of situation (usually) only happens in guilds with a wide range of player levels, if you're all closer together in levels the people you are allowed to fight for treasure will be around the same and would be "fairer" as to whether you feel guilty or not that's a personal thing, depending on what you want to "gift" back to them you could always ally them and give them solthing via ally only trade (unless they are less than level 10)  also once players are over level 100-1300ish depending on their boost point alotment, it's simply a matter of the cards they have and no longer limited by the number of boost points they have available, at that point you shouldn't really feel guilty so much anymore because you could potentially have similar decks power.