Talk:Guild Class/@comment-83.255.67.12-20131018143718/@comment-13515423-20131018174402

I believe all 3 bonuses would be equal, but since I run a dragonlord deck, I can't confirm that. I would just try all 3, record what numbers you get, and pick the highest.

Justice warrior would allow you to keep bonuses and swap in something other than a melee card if you needed to.

Soldier would allow you to swap in a non-justice melee.

Barbarian would always work. So if bonuses are equal, I think Barbarian would be the best.